A Comprehensive Comparison Between the S3910 and S5810 Series Switches

Overview of the S3910 and S5810 Series Switches

The S3910 series switches include S3910-24TS, S3910-24TF, S3910-48TS, and S3910-48TF. The 1G switches are Layer 2+ stackable managed gigabit Ethernet switches with full gigabit downlink and 1G/10G uplinks, featuring advanced hardware architecture and FSOS for improved performance and support for various routing protocols. The S5810 series switches are high-performance 10G L3 enterprise switches with up to 2.56T switching capacity, Broadcom® chips, extensive interface options, and advanced Layer 3 functionality, making them ideal for demanding enterprise networks.

S3910 vs. S5810: The Key Features

Performance and Processing Capability

S3910 Series Switches

The S3910 series Layer 2+ stackable managed switches are designed for modern gigabit Ethernet networks, featuring:

• Broadcom® chips: S3910-24T4S and S3910-48T6S use BCM56340, S3910-24TF and S3910-48TF use BCM56150.

• Switching Capacity: S3910-48TS can provide up to 176 Gbps switching capacity and 132 Mpps forwarding rate for exceptional network performance.

• New hardware architecture for increased resource entries, faster processing, and enhanced performance.

• Routing protocols like static routing, RIP, and OSPF to meet various network needs.

S5810 Series Switches

The S5810 series delivers high-performance 10G L3 enterprise switches with:

• Broadcom® chips: S5810-28TS and S5810-48TS use BCM56170, S5810-48SC use BCM56873.

• Switching Capacity: Up to 2.56T switching capacity for exceptional network throughput.

• Redundant hot-swappable power supplies and variable-speed fans ensure superior processing performance and network reliability.

• Advanced Layer 3 functionality, simplified management, IPv6 capabilities, and multicast protocols for complex enterprise networks.

Interfaces and Expandability

S3910 Series Switches

The S3910 series provides flexible and scalable network solutions with:

• Full Gigabit Downlink Ports: Ensuring robust connectivity for various network devices.

• Fixed 1G/10G Uplinks: Supporting high-speed data transfer and network expansion.

• Stackable Design: Allowing multiple switches to be interconnected and managed as a single unit for greater scalability.

• Modular Uplink Options: Enabling easy upgrades and expansions as network demands grow.

S5810 Series Switches

The S5810 series offers extensive interface options and superior expandability, ideal for enterprise networks:

• Fixed 1G/10G Ports: Providing high-speed connectivity for demanding applications.

• PoE+ ports: Supports up to 48 PoE+ ports with a total budget of 740W (only for S5810-48TS-P).

• Stackable Up to 8 Units: Seamless interconnection and management of multiple switches as a single device.

• Advanced Modularity: With multiple uplink module choices, providing superior expandability and future-proofing.

Power and Redundancy

This structured format succinctly outlines the power and redundancy features of both series, highlighting their suitability for different network environments.

S3910 Series Switches

• Energy Efficiency: Designed with an energy-efficient approach, featuring standard power supplies for consistent delivery and reduced power consumption.

• Reliability: Includes basic redundancy options such as hot-swappable power supplies and fans, ensuring minimal downtime and enhancing reliability.

S5810 Series Switches

• Advanced Features: Supports advanced redundancy protocols like VRRP and MLAG, crucial for maintaining stability in data centers and large enterprises.

• Power Efficiency: Balances high performance with energy efficiency, reducing overall power consumption and operational costs.

• Redundancy: Equipped with redundant hot-swappable power supplies and variable-speed axial fans for optimal cooling and reliability.

The Application of S3910 and S5810 Series Switches

The FS S3910 series and S5810 series switch cater to distinct network environments due to their specific capabilities and features below.

S3910 Applications: SMEs and Edge Computing

• Suited for small to medium-sized enterprises, edge computing environments, education, healthcare, and remote offices.

• Offers balanced performance, cost-effectiveness, and scalable interface options.

• Perfect for environments where network simplicity and efficiency are crucial, such as office networks, branch offices, and remote sites.

• Provides convenient wired access solutions to support IoT, mobile, and cloud applications for branch offices, and mid-market enterprises.

S5810 Applications: High-Performance Enterprise Networks

• Designed for data centers, large-scale enterprise networks, high-performance computing, virtualization, and cloud environments.

• Features advanced capabilities including extensive interface options and robust performance.

• Meets the rigorous demands of data center operations, including high traffic volumes, complex network architectures, and stringent uptime requirements.

• Ideal for core networking, data center interconnects, and large enterprise backbones.

How to Choose between the S3910 and S5810 Series Switches?

When deciding between the two series, consider your network's specific requirements.

Switching Capacity and Application

For higher switching capacity, select the S5810 series. For other requirements, the S3910 series will suffice. The S3910 series is ideal for the access layer. The S5810 series, on the other hand, is versatile enough to be deployed in the access layer of large campus networks and the aggregation layer of small to medium campus networks.

Network Management

The S5810 series offers two software versions. The version with PicOS® software is optimal for medium to large campus networks, significantly enhancing management efficiency with the integrated AmpCon™ management software. The version with FS's proprietary software supports various management methods, catering to the maintenance needs of conventional networks. The S3910 series currently runs on FS's proprietary software, with a future release planned for a PicOS® version, providing customers with flexibility based on their network requirements.

Conclusion

Both the S3910 and S5810 series switches are designed with specific market needs in mind. The S3910 series is tailored for small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and edge computing environments, offering a cost-effective, scalable, and efficient networking solution. In contrast, the S5810 series targets data centers and large enterprises, providing high performance, extensive scalability, and advanced features to support complex network environments. For further details on the two series switches, refer to the S3910 Series Switches Data Sheet or S5810 Series Switches Datasheet.